Iâve heard for a short while that YouTube was coming out with a new page design, and they were allowing some people to test it out. Looking back at how almost all new YouTube redesigns were failures, I didn’t opt in to this testing period, and wanted to wait as long as possible to switch to it, even when the design went public. Unfortunately, the design became mandatory today, and I was right in my prediction – it’s another horrible failure.
It appears like every time Google attempts to do a redesign for one of its products, it fails, regardless of how good the actual product itself is. I mentioned a while back that the new Gmail design is poor because it doesn’t have enough crisp and distinct contrast, and makes everything seem as if it’s merging together. I also stated that they have too much padding and space in all the wrong places. A similar thing happened to YouTube, where everything is now combined and it’s difficult to see the difference between different components of the website.
The YouTube home page basically looks like a feed now. Everything that your subscriptions do is now combined on the front, along with recommended channels and videos. It’s difficult to manage the content and identify what is where. There is a check box that allows you to view uploads only, but the helpfulness of that feature is marginal.
The biggest problem that I found with the new design is that you can no longer hide a subscription’s upload. I am the type of person who literally watches every video posted by his subscribers. Sometimes, I don’t have the time to watch a 10-minute-long video, but I do have time to watch a 2-minute-long video, so I’ll opt to watch the shorter video first and the longer video later. In the previous design, I was able to hit a small X icon at the top-right corner of the thumbnail of the video when I was done watching it so my subscriptions box only showed videos that I haven’t watched yet. The new design no longer has that, and doesn’t even have a symbol that tells you if you have watched a video or not.
Thus, this means that if I watch a video, it remains in my feed, and continues to push longer and potentially unwatched videos further and further down my feed. So, if my subscriptions post enough videos, I might end up not even noticing some videos if they get pushed down all the way by videos I have already watched.
Google’s products are great, and I support all of them (except Google Wave, which I thought was a slight failure), but they really need to get some better creative designers.