I’m a tad bit late posting this, but it’s better late than never – here is the response paper I wrote for my literature course for the sixth week of class. The first three paragraphs are my impressions, and the remainder of the paper is my critical analysis.

–

I decided to focus on “We Real Cool” by Gwendolyn Brooks because her poem was distinctly unique and different from the other nine poems, and it caught my attention in such a subtle but powerful way that it instantly became one of my favorite poems.

I believe that a powerful writer is able to tell intricate and complete stories in a succinct manner. This poem seems to fit that description very well. In 24 words, Brooks was able to essentially tell the life story about a group of pool players who chose to live the free life by only focusing on key events that define who they are.

She left out much of the detail most stories need to illustrate a vivid picture, but in Brooks’ poem’s case, because of the way it is written and how it progresses, the key words prompt our own images in our mind such that it is easy for us to visualize exactly what Brooks wanted us to visualize when reading her poem.

One thing that obviously sticks out in Gwendolyn Brooks’ “We Real Cool” is the way the poem is formatted in print. I decided to focus on the form of the poem and analyze how the way the poem is broken up contributes to the overall meaning of the poem.

There are eight lines, and every set of two lines are paired and separated into their own segment. The line break gives us a mental pause, as if it is the end of a scene and it is time to move on to the next; this is just like a scene transition in a movie where the video cuts from one location to another. Each paired segment has its own significance. The first opens the story by introducing the main characters of the story and gives background information about what they are like. The next gives us an idea about their lifestyle – they prefer to be active at night, and they are straightforward. The following segment tells us of their actions about what they do when they are together playing pool, singing and drinking alcohol. Finally, the last segment is the climax of the poem, where their actions get more intense and dangerous, like their promiscuity, and then includes the end of their lives when they die soon because of their poor choices. These breaks help tell the story because it provides a division between important aspects of their lives.

Another noticeable thing about the way the poem is formatted is how the word “We,” excluding the first line, is at the end of the previous line, rather than the beginning of each line. I believe this places emphasis on the actual activity rather than the people doing it. The “We” leads the first line because, not only is there no previous line, but because this is the only line where the focus is on the people. Afterwards, the “We” is at the end of the line as if the people are just afterthoughts, as if they do not really have a worthy identity because of the poor actions they choose to take. As the poem progresses, we begin to get accustomed to the rhythm and we begin to expect the “We” at the end of the final line, but it is not there. This leaves “Die soon.” on its own line, fitting its meaning – there is an abrupt and early ending to their lives because of their poor choices, just like there is an abrupt and seemingly early ending to the poem before we can get the comfort of the pattern of “We” at the end of the final line.

Overall, I think that this poem carries such power and influence not only because of the words Brooks chose to use to write it, but also because of the way it is formatted. The spacing and breaks included in the flow of the poem contribute a great deal to the impression it leaves on the reader, and because of the reasons stated above, it would lose a lot of its implicit meaning if the formatting were to be changed or removed.