Halloween 2010 Guaranteed Content: Bone Brooch vs. Skeletal Puppy
We recently saw the closing of a poll that was open to voting by both members and non-members: What would you like the Halloween 2010 Holiday Event reward to be? I, along with thousands of others, gave input by voting, and after the dust settled, the winner emerged: The Bone Brooch.
What is the Bone Brooch?
People that were around for the Easter Holiday Event a handful of years ago received a ring that, when activated, turned the character wearing the ring into an egg. This description may remind you of an enchanted Onyx Ring, which, when activated, turns the wearer into a set of rocks. The Bone Brooch will be just like these rings, but instead of transforming the player into an egg or some rocks, it would turn them into a pile of bones. In all these cases, the morphed player would still be able to talk and message friends, but would not be able to walk. I’m also pretty sure they cannot engage in any other skilling activities (such as alchemizing or fletching bows), but because I do not own either of the rings, I have not tested this theory out for myself.
What Did You Vote For?
I voted for the Skeletal Puppy, which would have been similar to the dogs and other animals that members can keep as pets (except it would be made out of bones). There were a lot of decent options in the poll, but the Skeletal Puppy was most unique compared to previous holiday event rewards. The Bone Brooch mentioned above was pretty clever, but there was already a similar item from a previous event. The non-following pet would have been good as well, but closely resembles Eek from Halloween 2009 and the summonable chipmunk from Easter 2010. A follower would have been completely unique, as it resembles no other previous rewards closely. It is arguable that the imp from the Christmas event is a follower, but the imp acts as more of a quest guide than a pet.
Shortening the Gap between Members and Non-Members
Something I was initially shocked to discover was that the free players did not all vote for the Skeletal Puppy and have it win by a landslide. Introducing followers to non-members would give them a taste of what Summoning is like for members. Although results would differ depending on public intake, a preview of a pet would most likely encourage more people to buy membership, as members can not only own a pet made of bones, but also own real animals and creatures (better known as Summoning familiars) with special abilities. The only two reasons I can think of that the Skeletal Puppy did not win drastically is that either the free players did not come to this conclusion, or the members that already have access to pets voted differently.
My Final Thoughts
I honestly don’t really care what the holiday event rewards are. After holiday items became untradeable, the essentially became useless. It’s not like I’m going to wear an item I got from a holiday event on a regular basis; I’m rich enough in-game to afford much better armor and clothing. The only reason I even do holiday events nowadays is because of the quest associated with the event that I eventually have to do anyway to get a Quest Point Cape of Achievement, and because I feel like I have to document my existence during the time of the holiday event. Even if the Halloween 2010 winner was the Skeletal Puppy, I still don’t think I would have used it in free worlds, as I’m not that big of a fan of having an undead creature following me around.
